Jack huffs a laugh, flustered by that for some reason. "Not so straight apparently, huh?" he says, rubbing the pad of his thumb between his eyebrows for a moment. "Pretty thorough and categorically debunked that."
Other options:
no subject
Jack huffs a laugh, flustered by that for some reason. "Not so straight apparently, huh?" he says, rubbing the pad of his thumb between his eyebrows for a moment. "Pretty thorough and categorically debunked that."