"This," says Newt. "I can't...I want to trust you so shucking badly." He covers his face with his long fingered hands. "I can't...All of it, Joe. All of it. Either it's...me. Or the rest of it. But I don't think you can have both anymore."
Other options:
no subject
"This," says Newt. "I can't...I want to trust you so shucking badly." He covers his face with his long fingered hands. "I can't...All of it, Joe. All of it. Either it's...me. Or the rest of it. But I don't think you can have both anymore."